QTA/FB

[fgcjnk at btinternet.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 14305

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Amy Z" <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> D
> O
> N
> '
> T
> 
> W
> A
> N
> T
> 
> T
> O
> 
> S
> P
> O
> I
> L
> 
> I
> T
> 
> !
> !
> !

> I just love the fact that the Chudley Cannons are the Red Sox of 
> Quidditch.  That fits Ron's character exactly right (no wonder he 
> feels like everything of his is rubbish...the martyr-complex of a 
> long-suffering fan).

Agreed - Totally in character

> >"4.  Was Harry violating the 6th rule of Quidditch when he pulled
> >out his wand to perform the Patronus Charm on the "Dementors" in 
PoA? 
>  Were
> >they "members of the crowd" for that purpose??"

> >Not a member of the crowd (this is the most questionable).
> >Seems like the rule has a little loophole there.
> 

I expect that the crowd are not allowed onto the pitch, so by being on 
the pitch they ceased to be memers of the crowd??

> Re: all the missing animals:  Dumbledore doesn't say so, but this 
must 
> be a drastically edited version of FB.  The actual schoolbook is 
> probably a 3-inch tome.  I was looking forward to reading about 
> Boggarts, though.
> 

Hmmm me too.

Florence