SPOILER: Why Draco Malfoy Isn't Evil - Canon Evidence
heidi.h.tandy.c92 at alumni.upenn.edu
heidi.h.tandy.c92 at alumni.upenn.edu
Tue Mar 20 14:22:10 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 14727
K
N
E
A
Z
L
E
S
-
N
O
W
A
N
D
F
O
R
E
V
E
R
Last week, after reading FB&WTFT, I was reviewing books 3 and 4 to
write my most recent chapter of Surfeit of Curses
(http://www.fanfiction.net/index.fic/index.fic?action=story-
read&storyid=96654) and something caught my eye.
Crookshanks reaction, or rather, is lack thereof, when Draco and his
cronies come into the train compartment.
As you all know, Crookshanks attacks Scabbers (aka Peter pettigrew
aka Wormtail) and when Hermione gets him to calm down, doesn't take
his eyes off him.
However, when Draco comes in, Crookshanks does nothing negative - it
would take only one line by JKR, something like "...and Crookshanks
woke up from his snooze and glowered at Malfoy..." or "...they didn't
even realize he was there until they heard Crookshanks hiss..." Lines
like that, on a reading of the books pre-FB&WTFT could have been
assumed as a regular catty reaction - but after reading about
Kneazles in FB&WTFT, it would've been clear to ALL of us that JKR was
saying that Draco was an "unsavoury or suspicious character".
But she didn't.
Now, she MAY be saying that Crookshanks has no reason to deem Draco
a "suspicious" character because they already know that he's an evil
git.
But if that was so, he'd still be unsavoury (ok, readers of Draco
Sinister, stop thinking that!!!!)
Any comments?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive