Quidditch questions (QTA)
Amy Z
aiz24 at hotmail.com
Sat Mar 24 15:15:02 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 15081
I was happy to see the question cleared up that was raised here a
couple of months ago: only the Seeker can catch, or for that matter
touch, the Snitch. So when they played Ravenclaw without Harry, they
had to designate another player Seeker. Two rules questions come to
mind now that I've pored over the rules in QTA:
-How do players know that they're straying towards the boundaries? It
must be hard to tell from 60 feet up; suddenly you're called out of
bounds and lose possession. The Seeker in particular could cause a
lot of trouble.
I think there should be some kind of boundary marker going, say, 100
feet up (however high players might typically fly), such as a charm
that makes you tingle if you get within a few feet of the boundary.
-The Snitch is enchanted to avoid capture while staying in bounds.
Does it have a height limit? I know the Seeker doesn't, so the Snitch
shouldn't either, but it seems to me a Snitch could cause a lot of
trouble by just hanging out in the stratosphere, staying technically
where the Seeker can find it, but for practical purposes out of reach.
Harry seems to stick pretty close to the action, suggesting that the
Snitch usually does the same.
Amy Z
-------------------------------------------------
watch this space for QTA/FB quotes now that the
spoiler-space requirement has been lifted!
-------------------------------------------------
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive