Raven or vampire?
aprilgc at ivillage.com
aprilgc at ivillage.com
Sun Mar 25 20:15:11 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 15147
"Sarah Waggott" <s_waggott at y...> wrote:
> Hi! Sorry if this topic has been discussed to death already, I
> trawled the archives for a long while and found no evidence of any
> similar posts.
>
> A while ago a debate raged as to whether Snape is a vampire or an
> animagus. I have never seen him as a vampire; yes he is pale, he
> wears black a lot, but so do goths and many other people.<snip>
I don't think he's a vampire. Wizards don't seem to care much for them.
I think he'd have left Lupin alone in PoA instead of making sure
everyone knew he was a ::gasp:: werewolf. You know, the pot calling
the kettle...
<snip>
>~ Animagi are rare (I think) so two in the school would be likely to stay close to each other and the headteacher.
But if he were a registered Animagi, Hermione would know about it
already since she's done that research in PoA.
>
> It could also be a factor in Snape's hatred of the Marauders. If
> becoming an Animagus is hard work, I would imagine it would be nice
> to feel part of a very select group. Imagine the shock when it turns
> out that not only have others in the school completed the training,
> they just happen to be your worst enemies, the ones you like to feel
> superior to. It could also be a reason why Snape didn't push for
> their expulsion; he may have found respect for them. Not the kind of
> respect Harry has for Dumbledore or anything, more like that nagging
> little voice that says: "Maybe they're not so bad after all..."
>
<snip>
I think, though, that Snape doesn't find out the SB is an Animagus
until GoF. Had he known, considering that he thinks SB's a criminal,
he would have told the authorities -- and what better way to get rid
of/even with Lupin than to alert the authorities that he aided/abetted
by his silence.
I'm not saying that Snape isn't an Animagus (maybe Hermione overlooked
his registration, or he's not registered). I just don't think it
influenced his feelings towards MWPP because he didn't know about them.
a.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive