Ginny telling TGHP where to get off
cassandraclaire at mail.com
cassandraclaire at mail.com
Thu Mar 29 23:05:01 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 15551
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Amy Z" <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> Cassie wrote:
>
> >I bet she'd really like some character
> >development where she got to be brave, or do something
interesting,
> >or maybe got to tell the Great Harry Potter where to get off, just
> >once.
>
> Sigh. Didn't I already give a good example? Okay, I'll write it
> out. This is from memory so please don't jump on me for getting my
> prepositions wrong!
---------------------------
I promise not to jump on you. I remember this scene has already been
mentioned, by you and by others. I'd agree with Penny's
interpretation of it "Then, we have Ginny's one shining moment in the
pre-Yule Ball scene." I also think of it as her one shining moment
and it gives me a glimmer of hope for her in the future. I don't
really think of it as a telling-Harry-where-to-get-off scene; she's
being a little feisty, towards him and Ron, but I doubt she would
have said anything if it had been just Harry there, and she hadn't
been semi-exasperated with Ron about his general attitude about the
Ball. It's a nice little moment, but I was thinking of something
larger-scale, something that would show she's outgrown her hero-
worshipping infatuation with Harry; IMHO, that scene doesn't quite
show that. But it certainly is a jump-off point for hopes for the
future.
And I already took back the boring wimp comment! Peace! Pax!
Cassie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive