Snape Returned to LV?

[naama_gat at hotmail.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 18317

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Bugg" <bugganeer at y...> wrote:
> Nothing I remember reading proves Snape has not gone back to LV. 
> LV passed at least one DE without mentioning his/her name. 
> Snape would not have been able to stop LV from killing Cedric 
> or trying to kill Harry. LV may have mentioned three DE at 
> Hogwarts as not to give Snape's identitity away to other DEs 
> or there may be yet another DE at Hogwarts we do not know about. 
> 
> Bugg 
> 

I think Snape has gone back to Voldy, but after Harry had returned 
(the scene at the hospital, when Snape leaves to do accomplish some 
unspecified, but obviously dangerous, mission). 
I don't think it is possible for Snape to have attended the DE 
meeting. The main reason, IMO, is that he just didn't have enough 
time to return. Within ten-fifteen minutes of Harry's return, 
Dumbledore, McConagall and SNAPE were breaking down Moody's door and 
rescuing Harry. Now, Harry returned via a portkey, which is 
practically instantaneous. But you can't Apparate in Hogwarts. So - 
how could Snape return so quickly? Besides, it would be too 
noticeable that Snape wasn't arround in such an emergency as the 
disappearance of two students in such a way. Also, he can't 
Disapparate from Hogwarts, so when the DE come popping arround Voldy, 
Snape would have had to pop up quite a while later, which we know 
didn't happen. They all arrived at almost the same time.
Taking all that together, it just doesn't fit. It's a nice theory but 
it doesn't work. If Snape returned to Voldy, it had to be after Harry 
returned, not before.



Naama
VIP
Nitpicking Department