D&H as Seekers - Ravenclaw location - Dreams - Lexicon

Amy Z aiz24 at hotmail.com
Fri May 11 22:16:57 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 18575

Catlady wrote:

>in PoA, he won three of the four matches he was in, and would
>have won the fourth except that Harry had that Firebolt <snip>

>"He knocked Malfoy's arm out of the way ... he pulled out of his dive
>..." My point is, only a Firebolt could pull of a dive THAT sharply 
and
>fast. If Harry had had 'merely' a Nimbus 2001, he might have grabbed 
the
>Snitch out of Draco's hand, but would have crashed hard into the 
ground
>immediately thereafter, thus releasing the Snitch for Draco to catch 
again.

Maybe, maybe not.  I agree that Draco is a very good Seeker, based on 
his record.  However, to give the Firebolt this much credit for 
Harry's victory seems a tad insulting to Harry's talent.  What in this 
passage indicates that he couldn't have done this on a Nimbus 2000?

>I got the feeling that the Ravenclaw common room is down in the
>dungeons, from the CoS scene in which polyjuiced Harry and Ron are
>looking for the Slytherin common room and run into Penelope the
>Ravenclaw prefect.

She was there for some privacy with Percy, whom Ron and Harry also run 
into there.

>I assumed that the Quirrell's turban dream and the following 
something silvery dream were also just normal dreams about 
>what the waking mind is worrying about.  

What about the sound of hooves in the latter?  Could be coincidence, 
but it seems so specific as to be prophetic. 

Mea culpa on referring people to a specific page of the Lexicon in my 
Britishisms post.  If you want to visit the Lexicon, and you do, 
believe me, go to the home page so Steve gets a hit:

http://www.i2k.com/~svderark/lexicon/

Then make your way to whatever you're interested in.

Amy Z

---------------------------------------------------------
 "No one wants to read about some ugly old Armenian
 warlock, even if he did save a village from werewolves.  
 He'd look dreadful on the front cover.  No dress sense 
 at all."
                         -HP and the Chamber of Secrets
---------------------------------------------------------





More information about the HPforGrownups archive