Suspended Our Words (filk)

[Amy Z]

No: HPFGUIDX 18919

Caius Marcius wrote:

> > Author's Note: Something I just recently noticed is that Draco's 
> > sidekicks Crabbe and Goyle, though they are variously described as 
> > sniggering, grinning, laughing, rubbing their knuckles, chuckling 
> > trollishly, chortling, etc., etc, have no dialogue assigned to 
them 
> > at all in the entire series.  

Joywitch wrote:
> 
> Interesting observation, CMC, and great filk!  I never realized it 
> before, but I think you are right...I can not remember even one 
> specific word ever uttered out loud by Crabbe or Goyle. Is JKR doing 
> this on purpose?  Will they someday speak to us, thus revealing 
> something important?  Or will they grunt and snigger their way thru 
> all 7 books?

Having recently concluded that they haven't spoken, I was hoping on my 
last re-listen of GF that the senior Crabbe and Goyle would also only 
grunt, but IIRC, they mutter some audible words.  

Great filk as always, CM!

Amy Z

-------------------------------------------------------
 Ron, who had been gazing at Harry, said, "You don't
 know how bizarre it is to see Goyle =thinking=."
                        -HP and the Chamber of Secrets
-------------------------------------------------------