Red Flags, Red Herrings

[jenfold at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 19088

> > BERTHA JORKIN
> > Who did Bertha see kissing Florence behind the greenhouse?
> 
> Ah....I like this question.  I use to think it was Snape but I now 
> lean toward this being Sirius.  As I stated on the *Snapesfans* 
site, 
> Sirius comments at two different times about how nosy Bertha was.  
> Why should Sirius care that Bertha caught him kissing Florence 
unless 
> Florence was Snape's girl (or someone else's) and he didn't want 
> Snape to find out.  As you can tell, I am not a Lily/Snape 
believer.  
> Anyway, if Sirius kisses Snape's girl, I don't imagine Snape would 
be 
> very happy about that.  Also, after that kiss Florence would 
realize 
> that there could be no other for her except Severus......the real 
man 
> at Hogwarts! 
>  


 I've had a very similar thought floating around my head for ages. 
There just seems to be more going on in the conflict between Sirius 
and Snape compared to the one between James and Snape in my opinion. 
And an argument over the mysterious Florence had ocured to me too 
(the Lily thing never happened). Finally someone has the same 
theories, possibly if I point it out to my friends they'll stop 
giving me funny looks. 

 Yay I'm not mad, or perhaps we're both insane.

 Jen

 Member of the SAS (Snape appreciation society)