[HPforGrownups] moving pictures ... paintings vs. photos

Tamfiiris tamf at matavnet.hu
Mon May 28 19:22:02 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 19654

Doreen Rich wrote:

> Does it specifically *say* somewhere in the books or in a JKR
> discussion, that *only* paintings' subjects can move about, from
> painting to painting? Does it *say* that photo subjects can not move
> from photo to photo, or from photo to painting? Or are we just to
> assume, since only the paintings' subjects have done it so far, that
> the photos' subjects can not? I am really curious about this one.

well, i don't have any concrete evidence, sorry. but i think we can
assume that photos mainly don't move around much, snapshots of the
moment as they are. they didn't seem to have done so in Harry's photo
album of his parents, for example. i assume more 'soul' or magic
substance has gone into creating the paintings, giving them more life
and character.

ciao
Tamf






More information about the HPforGrownups archive