[HPforGrownups] Obliviation - Snape at 3rd task? at rebirthing? - Who knew about SB - CoS

[Magda Grantwich]

No: HPFGUIDX 19848

>I thought that Snape flinching was evidence that
>he was not at the DE scene - if he had been he would have known
> who they were and that Harry could identify them.  The flinching 
> might be because Snape had hoped that Malfoy wouldn't go back to 
> Voldemort -
> maybe he cares about Draco.  Or are you suggesting that he didn't
> want Harry to blurt what they both knew, or that he thought Harry
> was about to finger *him*?

I think Snape's starting at Malfoy's name is a red herring that JKR
has planted (mixed metaphors but you get the idea).  We're supposed
to think that it's Malfoy's name that Snape is reacting to but the
fact that Harry can name them for some reason.  But we'll all be
watching the Malfoy's all the closer now. 

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get personalized email addresses from Yahoo! Mail - only $35 
a year!  http://personal.mail.yahoo.com/