Authorial Misinformation

[dfrankiswork at netscape.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 27017

My formal knowledge of English Literature is zilch, so, as we might say in our corporate sales literature, David brings to the problem a fresh approach uncluttered by preconceptions.  So here's an attempt at kick-starting.

Rather than attempt abstract definitions, I will suggest some concrete examples to show how I think it works.

If Hagrid says that all dark wizards came from Slytherin, we don't have to believe him.  He might be mistaken, or prejudiced.

If Harry thinks Hermione looks stunning at the ball, we don't have to take that at face value.  It's a subjective opinion.

If the narrative says that Hermione's teeth got longer, that really happened.  If Harry sees that Hermione's teeth have shrunk, that really happened, unless we are in a situation where illusions are known to be a possibility.

If debate in the bar at the Hanged Man at Little Hangleton, is reported verbatim, that reportage is factually correct.

If Dumbledore says that Lily's sacrifice prevented Quirrell from touching Harry, we tend to believe him, because of his known character and knowledge.  However, we realise he might not be telling the whole truth, though he wouldn't tell a partial truth that would mislead.

If Snape tells Harry Boomslang skin has been stolen from his office, we evaluate based on Snape's known character.  He tends to tell the literal truth, but may be selective to further his own interpretation and purpose.  If Harry goes on to jump to conclusions that this refers to the COS incident, that's Harry's responsibility.  We don't have to follow him.  But JKR doesn't have to actively prevent us, either.

I do have a problem that the principles embodied in the above examples don't fully resolve.  I will try to post it off separately when I get the chance.

Hope that helps.  Any comments, Luke?

David


__________________________________________________________________
Your favorite stores, helpful shopping tools and great gift ideas. Experience the convenience of buying online with Shop at Netscape! http://shopnow.netscape.com/

Get your own FREE, personal Netscape Mail account today at http://webmail.netscape.com/