Malfoy, Crabbe, & Goyle in book 5

Milz absinthe at mad.scientist.com
Wed Oct 3 18:29:05 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 27087

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., bookraptor11 at y... wrote:
 
> In book five, do you think Draco and the others will come back to 
> Hogwart's as students?  I think their parent's would see this as a 
> good way of trying to keep an eye on Dumbledore.  Also, from what 
> I've seen of Dumbledore, I don't see him barring them.  He would 
> believe that they were not beyond redemption and would want to give 
> them every chance to choose differently from their parents.
> 
> However, with concrete evidence that Voldemort lives and is massing 
> his forces, 
> how are they going to get any teaching and learning done?  What will 
> happen among the Slytherins, since not all of them are V. 
supporters? 
> I'm not sure if I'm putting that right, but that house is going to 
be 
> a hellish place, IMO

Good question. Dumbledore says at the feast that everyone present in 
the Great Hall will always be welcome at Hogwarts...MCG were present 
too, so this includes them. Therefore, I doubt Dumbledore will expell 
them or even discourage them from attending Hogwarts.

I have a feeling the MCG will be attending Hogwarts in Book 5. Why? I 
have had the impression that Lucius Malfoy used Draco as his informant 
during CoS since I read the book. Strategically, MCG are well-placed 
to be conduits of information to the Dark Side about the goings-on in 
Hogwarts.

Milz





More information about the HPforGrownups archive