Yet Another Flint? -- Fudge and the Dementors
cynthiaanncoe at home.com
cynthiaanncoe at home.com
Fri Oct 5 21:56:32 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 27208
In PoA, the Dementors try to give Harry the kiss and then retreat.
When this happens, Snape, Black, Hermione, and Ron all are
unconscious, and Lupin and Pettigrew have run off. Harry is the only
wizard who has first-hand knowledge of the events.
Nevertheless, Fudge makes two remarks concerning the behavior of the
dementors. First in "Herione's Secret":
"What amazes me most is the behavior of the dementors . . . you've
really no idea what made them retreat, Snape?"
"No, Minister . . . . by the time I had come 'round they were heading
back to their positions at the entrances."
Then in "Owl Post Again":
"And the dementors?" said Dumbledore. "They'll be removed from the
school, I trust?"
"Oh yes, they'll have to go," said Fudge, running his fingers
distractedly through his hair. "Never dreamed they'd attempt to
administer the Kiss on an innocent boy . . . . Completely out of
control . . . no, I'll have them packed off back to Azkaban
tonight . . . . Perhaps we should think about dragons at the school
entrance . . . "
How does Fudge learn that something drove the dementors off at all,
or that they tried to Kiss Harry? Aren't the only people who could
have told Fudge about this the dementors themselves? Does this mean
Fudge may have some relationship with the dementors that we don't
fully understand? Or is this just a Flint?
Cindy (wondering who makes the call about what is or is not a real
Flint)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive