[HPforGrownups] Chamber of Secrets/Diary

[laura hickman]

No: HPFGUIDX 27638


--- UcfRentLuvr at cs.com wrote:
> Your point about JKR telling us "we'll see" is a
good point.  However, I don't know if the time-turner
would be used again.  I feel that somewhere between
book 5 and 7 we will learn how Tom knew his future
self disliked (I know quite a soft term) Harry, or
also I did like your idea about Ginny telling Tom
about Harry and Vol, maybe even if Tom didn't know the
whole truth about why he was after Harry, knowing that
later in life he had problems with Harry, knowing if
he could get rid of him anyway possible, then his
future self may even have a better life.  True, if you
think about it, since Tom tried to get rid of Harry
after his older self already lost to him, why should
Tom want to get rid of Harry, unless somehow he (young
Tom) knew what happened between Harry and Vol.  I
really have been wondering about that.  You know maybe
that's why most people seem to think CoS is their
least fave book, probably because we don't know why
Tom would go after HP since Vol's defeat couldn't be
changed even if Tom destroyed Harry bc it was 12 yrs
later.

I don't know... any ideas?  However, just talking
about the time-turner... just for all know know... PoA
is my fave book... probably because Harry does get
(just for a minute) a family, and he does have the
best line in very end of the book, about Siris and how
Siris will be waiting for info on how Harry's being
treated.  Maybe it's also because the reader gets alot
of extra back history!  Who knows... I know I'm
rambling... maybe someone can give some other ideas on
both the time-turner and why Tom wants to kill Harry!

Laura Waid
:)

Can't wait for BOOK 5...  still very unpatiently
waiting@!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
> 
> But then again, another thought occured to me.
> Someone once asked JKR in a 
> chat if the Time-Turner would ever come into play
> again. IIRC, she replied 
> "We'll see" or "I'm not telling"--something alon
> those lines. Maybe Harry 
> goes back in time to fight
> Tom, for whatever reason, and the point that they
> get there is before Tom has 
> made the diary. Then, when Tom does make the diary,
> he kind of already knows 
> that he wants to go after Harry...but then that
> requires that Harry not 
> defeat Tom. Time-travling is so confusing.
> 
> Any thoughts on this confusing topic? :)
> 
> 
> ***Dixie Malfoy***
>     
>     
> 
> 
> 
> 
> [Non-text portions of this message have been
> removed]
> 
> 


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make a great connection at Yahoo! Personals.
http://personals.yahoo.com