Why CoS is the least favorite

Janie jane_1w at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Oct 17 07:37:44 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 27790

I like CoS because it has Ginny in it! I also like it because Harry 
isn't totally the focus of the story, it also has the added human 
interest thing, with Ginny being captured by Tom Riddle. BUT i know 
that a lot of people prefer the other books, especially Gof, and to 
be honest, that has a lot more excitement than CoS, but i like it!

Janie
xxx



--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Maxwell Simpson <usergoogol at y...> wrote:
> Although I like the book, I think the main problem is that 1, 3, 
and 4 have things which HP doesn't.
> 
> 1) The introductory book is excellent. It introduces everything 
about Harry, it has the Mirror of Erised, and I think Voldie was very 
intriguing in thise one.
> 
> 3) It has Lupin, a fan-favorite, it has Boggarts, it has Hogsmeade, 
it has a guy breaking out of jail, it has a surprising and complex 
ending, and it has Sirius Black in his less criminal form, who is a 
very nice guy, once you get to know him. Plus it really tells alot of 
the back story, and everyone loves that.
> 
> 4) The newest, it has the World Cup, it has far more Weasleys than 
any other previous book, it has the Triwizard Competition, and it has 
the rebirth of Voldemort.
> 
> Book two is nice, it introduces the Weasley family, Tom Riddle, and 
House Elves. All three are very important. It introduces Penelope 
Clearwater, who isn't particually important, but she could be. It has 
Lockhart, who _I_ found amusing (I voiced him with a cross between 
Troy McLure of the Simpsons and another pompous person. Very deep, 
very loud.) It also explains why Hagrid was kicked out of Hogwarts.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive