apparation at Hogwarts

[lisa palmer]

No: HPFGUIDX 27955


Hermione says that House Elves possess powerful magic of their own. And in fact, we have seen many examples of House Elf magic, Aunt Petunia's pudding escapade, the platform, and the bludger.   But we don't really have a way of knowing how closely related the magic of elves is to wizards. In book 4 however,  Winky is suspected of using a wizard's wand, so perhaps magic is magic, House elf or wizard.  The reason why this matters to me is that in Book two, Dobby dissapears at Hogwarts with a "CLAP".  Is this apparating at Hogwarts? In all four of the books I think Hermione mentions at least once that it is impossible to apparate on Hogwarts grounds, and that it says so in Hogwarts, A History.  Do you think Dobby is apparating? Did Hermione misread? Or is this only a myth of Hogwarts, that everyone is too afraid to test, after all, apparating is a nasty business which can get you splinched. I am eager to here what people's opinons are on this. 

 



---------------------------------
Do You Yahoo!?
Make a great connection at Yahoo! Personals.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]