[HPforGrownups] Minerva Not In On Black's Secret

[Calypso8604 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 28304

I never noticed until you mentioned it but it does seem as if Dumbledore sent 
Minerva away. Perhaps it was a mix between having her actually do the task 
she was sent out for (calling Hagrid and Olympe to his office) and making 
almost everyone leave before the confrontation between Snape and Sirius. 
Although, I'm not exactly sure why Minerva shouldn't be there...

~ Calypso





In a message dated 10/27/01 9:10:45 PM Eastern Daylight Time, 
doseylel at aol.com writes:


> It has always bothered me at the end of GoF, that Dumbledore sends 
> Minerva off before having Sirius transform.  She is the Deputy 
> Headmistress, and should something happen to Dumbledore, she would be 
> in charge.  Isn't this an important bit of information in the fight 
> against Voldemort?  Shouldn't she also know about the Old Crowd?  Has 
> anyone else thought that was strange?
> 
> Leslie 
> 
> 




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]