Observations and Questions

[cynthiaanncoe at home.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 25574

Luke wrote:> Actually, again (sorry!), I must point out that we don't 
have proof 
> that Stan and Ernie know more than Mme. Rosmerta.
> 
> Looking at the scene they seem to know that Sirius (allegedly) 
killed 
> thirteen people (and allegedy laughed about it), but they don't 
seem 
> to know anything about him (allegedly) betraying the Potters, which 
is 
> the thing Mme. Rosmerta is being informed about in this scene.
> 
> Stan also seems to think Sirius was up to be V.'s second-in-
command, 
> but this is of course just a false rumor so whether Rosmerta knew 
that 
> or not would be of no consequence.
> 

Doh!  Wrong again!  Strike two! Looks like it's about time I put down 
GoF and worked my way back through PoA, as I'm clearly getting a 
little rusty.

Cindy (who absolutely HATES to be wrong)