Professor Trelawney Scorecard?

[Joanne Collins]

No: HPFGUIDX 25988

Cindy wrote:

>Good point.  If we are going to determine whether Trelawney is a 
>fraud or not, we need to compare a list of her correct predictions 
>versus her incorrect ones.
>
>People born in July are "in great danger of sudden violent deaths" -- 
>True (Well, maybe.  Harry certainly was in great danger in GoF.)
>Harry was born in mid-winter -- False

I was thinking, could that be a misprint rather than an error from
Trelawney? Perhaps the editor/person who let it pass was from
Australia/somewhere about this end of the world and July *is* mid-winter to
them and they didn't pick up on it as an error?

Just a thought.

Joanne.

-- 

For Holden, love isn't blind, it just needs corrective eyewear.
DVD blurb for Chasing Amy.

Some doors should never be opened.
Banky Edwards, Chasing Amy.

In love, you have to put the individual ahead of their actions. Always.
Holden McNeil, Chasing Amy.