RL's Fate/SB's Fate

[cynthiaanncoe at home.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 26639

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Amy Z" <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> Cindy wrote:
> 
> > Lupin's problem isn't
> > that people criticize him or dislike him.  It is that people 
assume
> > he is expendable.
> 
> I was going to respond, but Luke said everything that was on my 
mind 
> perfectly.
> 
> The death that will "half-crucify" JKR in OoP is NOT Lupin, unless 
we 
> allow for the wereghost possibility, because she has said that he 
will 
> play a role in book 7:
> 

Amy, now you've got me a little worried.  We know that JKL never does 
the obvious.  That, and the evidence you provide that Lupin will 
appear in Book 7, suggests that he is safe for now.  (Whew!)  

So who has a bulls-eye on his or her back?  In the Derby, I don't 
think anyone suggested Sirius would die.  But aside from Harry, 
Sirius is the character who faces the most "risk."  He could die at 
the hands of Voldemort, MoM, or a dementor.  It also fits that it 
would half-crucify JKR to write Sirius' demise (it would half-crucify 
me, anyway), and it would satisfy Luke's theory that we can't just 
have peripheral characters dying.

That means we need a Sirius club, and in a hurry, too.  Acronyms, 
anyone?

Cindy (who would sacrifice Ginny AND Neville to save Sirius)