Why do Muggles get a capital letter?
GulPlum
plumeski at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 8 19:01:50 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 37581
"... Weaver ..." <weaver at s...> wrote:
> Why are there 'Muggles' and 'wizards'? Why not 'muggles' and
wizards, or
> Muggles and 'Wizards'? Surely it makes more sense to be
consistent?
<snip>
I don't think it has anything to do with English usage. What I
suspect it has a lot to do with is intellectual property law (stand
up Ms Stouffer) - note that almost all JKR-invented terminology or
words with a specific meaning within the Potterverse are capitalised:
Transfigure, Apparate, Muggle, etc, etc.
It is much easier to establish special meaning (and thus trademarks)
for capitalised words (the traditional use of capital initials
relates to proper nouns) - using non-capitals means that the author
is allowing non-specialist use.
Note also that "wizard", "witch", or indeed "magic", don't get
capital initials as these are words used in their standard English
meaning. In this way, JKR is underlining the fact that capitalised
words have a special meaning - e.g. Transfiguration isn't used in its
Christian (Catholic) sense, but something slightly different,
although related.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive