BIG PROBLEM WITH FOURTH MAN! HELP!

[lucky_kari]

No: HPFGUIDX 37972

I was about to explain fourth man to my brother, when he knocked a 
whole in it that left me flabbergasted.

He said the fourth man is obviously the third Death Eater, dead in 
Voldemort's service. And the more I thought about this the more 
horrifically it made sense. All the Voldemort-adressed gaps in the 
circle should artistically refer to DEs throughout the novel. The 
first two dead in V's service are obviously Rosier and Wilkes, but the 
third? And, why doesn't he mention the fourth man... well, because the 
fourth man is the third man, since dead at Azkaban, dead in V's 
service.

Does this mean we have to release Avery? Oh, I hope not.

Eileen, clutching at Avery, "HE'S MINE, I TELL YOU! PETTIGREW AND 
MALFOY CAN'T HAVE HIM!"