Harry, Dumbledore, Fawkes & Flamel/Crouch Jr

[Karen Peirson]

No: HPFGUIDX 38024


cmf_usc wrote:
>so I was wondering if ya'll had ideas about what types of pets >might be particularly useful to Harry?

I haven't done an achive search on this *sorry*, but when I heard the third book was to be called 'The Order of the Pheonix' it occured to me that Harry may be bestowed AD's pheonix, Fawkes - maybe after AD's death. No I don't have any specific cannon for this, but throughout GoF we are drawn to the fact that AD is looking old and tired, and Fawkes appears to have formed an attachment to Harry - lands on his lap in AD's office afer the third task.

And just an additional thought, maybe AD, was in fact being kept alive by the same elixior as Flamel from the philosopher's stone, and he is in fact running low on his stock pile of the life prolonging substance.


Also there was a previous discussion about Crouch Jr.

finwitch wrote:

>As I read it, I was totally convinced Jr. did *not* do it. That he 
>was just another innocent sent to Azkaban. 

There is a problem with this idea that Crouch Jr. was innocent before the trial, and it was only his treatment that sent him over to the dark side. 

The problem is that the DEs leave a space for the 'faithful' servant in the circle after LV rebirth (assuming this is refering to Crouch Jr.). If Crouch Jr. did not go over to the dark side until after LV's downfall then there would have been no opportunity for the DEs to know there was any need for an extra space.


Hope this makes sense - be gentle with your relpies this is my first message after being a lurker for a short while.

Karen


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]