Pettigrew's debt to Harry

tmarends tmarends at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 1 19:25:05 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 41981

Jackie wrote:
>>>The spell which brings Voldemort back to life? "Flesh of the 
>*servant*, willingly
> taken..." I think JKR worded this VERY carefully. I think the
> "willingly taken" bit might also cause a teensy problem, since Peter
> was obviously frightened into doing it. :)
> 
> We haven't seen any evidence so far that this has made him any 
weaker,
> or more vulnerable to Harry, but I'm also interested in seeing how 
JK
> will tackle this subject in future books - might it affect 
Voldemort in
> the same way that Lily's sacrifice does? As Dumbledore said in 
SS/PS,
> the one thing Voldemort can't understand is love. Well, it seems to 
me
> he doesn't really *get* the whole forgiveness/kindness thing, 
either.
> :)
> 


It was "Flesh of the servant willingly *given*"...  What was *taken* 
was Harry's blood... and, according to the spell, that was "forcibly 
taken".  Peter might have had is doubts, but he willingly gave up his 
hand.  He also got a new shiny silver one to replace it.  Don't you 
use silver to kill a warewolf??

Tim A.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive