Pettigrews debt to Harry

bboy_mn bboy_mn at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 1 23:10:46 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 41989

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Richasi" <richasi at a...> wrote:
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

> Darrin Wrote:
> 
> > ... edited by previous poster.... end, and who will die 
> > and who will live. My heart tells me I want  Harry to 
> >live but my brain tells me it would be a dynamite ending to 
> >a story to have -- and I can't take credit for this; a poster 
> >whose name I can't remember suggested it -- Hermione and Ron 
> >looking at the Mirror of Erised and seeing their lost friend 
> >Harry.

Richasi Replies to Darrin:
> 
> You know, I don't think I've really thought about that until 
> just now. One part of me would say having Harry die is a fitting 
> end to the story. It'd be tragic but predictable. If there's one
> thing that we might get from this is that it is usually the 
> innocent who get killed. So, while it might be poignant 

>(and  rather spooky. Just visualizing the image of Hermoine and 
> Ron staring into  the mirror sent chills down my spine), it might 
> be even more poignant to have Harry and Hermoine or Harry and Ron
> staring in... in a tribute to not only lost friends, but of 
> those who were innocent.
> 
> Richasi

bboy_mn coments:

I would like to encourage everyone to read post#41480 Titled:
Devastation & Heartbreak (re: Horrible to Write) 

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/41480

Where I made some comments about the impact of Harry Potter dying at
the end of the book. 

In summary of that, If Harry dies, I can see an international day of
moarning that will nearly bring the world to a stop. The little boy
who was the most heartfelt best friend of the world will have died. I
see schools closing. I see businesses crippled. I see every magazine,
TV show, and newspaper eulogizing the best loved boy in the world. I
see a lot of tears falling for a long time. 

If that's how Rowings wroteit, then I think she should stay true to
that and leave it as is. But I truly see international devastation if
Harry Potter dies; heartbreading devastation the likes of which the
world has never see.

Call me crazy, call me sentimental, call me a barmy old codger, but
that's what I see.

bboy_mn







More information about the HPforGrownups archive