[HPforGrownups] Dumbledore Animagus?
Richelle Votaw
rvotaw at i-55.com
Tue Aug 13 03:04:31 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 42545
Ginny writes:
> I'm not caught up, so I apologize if this is a repeat of anything in
> the last 100 messages or so.
>
> 1. Is Dumbledore an animagus, and if so what form? I agree that he
> ought to be, and that a bumblebee makes sense from etymology (which
> is, interestingly enough, only one letter different than entymology,
> assuming I'm spelling correctly). However, if that were the case,
> it would have been very easy for JK to slip little hints and
> foreshadowings in. So-and-so swats at a bee that seems to be very
> interested in their conversation, someone hears a buzzing nearby but
> it flies away before they see it, like that. But she didn't. Or at
> least I don't remember anything like that. Anyone prove me wrong?
I can't think of any bees or buzzing, however, there is the statement
Dumbledore made to Harry at the Mirror of Erised. "I don't need a cloak to
become invisible." Did he mean literally invisible? I don't know that
there's any canon to support that a wizard can be invisible without
assitance of a cloak or some such thing. So perhaps he didn't mean
literally invisible? In a castle the size of Hogwarts, a bumblebee flying
high overhead would not be noticed. Especially in a room with the Mirror of
Erised and Harry's attention focused on that. There's also the fact that
Harry thought he "must have walked straight past him [Dumbledore], so
desperate to get to the mirror he hadn't noticed him." Or perhaps he was
in Bumblebee form, much easier to miss than a full grown wizard like
Dumbledore! He could've been waiting as a bumblebee and transfigured after
Harry walked by him. I've always found it a little odd that Harry would
completely not notice Dumbledore sitting on a desk, no matter how desperate
he was to get to the mirror.
Richelle
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive