Animagi, Hedwig and Forbidden Forest
kangasboy
pat_mahony at hotmail.com
Tue Aug 13 08:26:08 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 42550
Logically speaking, it is quite likely that Dumbledore is an
animagus; teaching transfiguartion, etc.
If so, then what form?
Various posters, Ginny and Richelle being the most recent, have
suggested that, given Dumbledore's etymology, this form could
be a bumblebee. One of the strengths of this theory, if it turns out
to be true, is that it would be a wonderful irony; most powerfl
wizard becomes seemingly powerless creature.
Another theory floating around is that Fawkes is Dumbledore's
animagus form, and Dumbledore is using a time turner
whenever he appears in the same room. This could work, and
provides a literal explanation for Dumbledore's comments about
never truly leaving the school. Unfortunately, the issue of time
travel makes it a very messy theory, and I don't think this is likely
(although I'm sure JKR would be able to make it otherwise).
Another possibility is Hedwig. I think an owl is a good animagus
form for someone as wise as Dumbledore, plus there is at least
a physical resemblance in the colouring. However, there is the
issue of Hedwig being female, but it is quite reasonable to
suggest that Harry has no idea how to distinguish genders in
owls.
I think that Hedwig is an animagus, but I actually think that
Hedwig is in fact Madame Hooch. When Hagrid bought Hedwig,
Harry wasn't with him, plus Hooch clears up gender problems.
There is also the point of Madame Hooch's yellow, hawk-like
eyes, and I think this is the strongest evidence to suggest that
she is Hedwig.
Now I realise that there is a problem with the list of unregistered
animagi, and I think it highly unlikely that we'd have another
unregistered animagus. However, there are a number of ways
around this: What if Madame Hooch is married, and registered
before she got married? We are unaware of her first name, plus
JKR in an interview (I forget which), refused to answer a question
concerning the marital status of the Hogwarts teacher. Plus she
is a 'Madame", which if I remember my French properly, which is
the equivalent of "Mrs".
On a completely different topic, bboy_mn wrote:
"the werewolves in the forest are older experienced werewolves.
. .Lupin on the other hand is a 12 year old schoolboy. . .
Does that cover it?"
I suppose so, but I still don't fully believe that there are
werewolves in the Forest. . . The whole concept of the forest as
has been presented to us seems far too much of a cliche, for
Rowling's standards. . . No, I think there is something much
more important to do with the forest, other than a plot device.
Roo
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive