The Importance of Being Neville (was Re: who is who--trio vs maruauders)

fyredriftwood fyredriftwood at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 14 04:18:49 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 42614

Richelle kindly replied to my post with:

>I think eventually Neville will face a huge decision.  Either to 
betray his
> friends and save himself or stand up and fight for them and risk 
his life.
> I believe he will choose to fight (whether Voldemort or a death 
eater I
> don't know)  and possibly die.  This is where the similarities 
between he
> and Peter will cease.  Neville will choose the right road, even if 
it means
> death, whereas Peter chose the wrong road.  When and if Neville 
does die, I
> will probably cry.  Poor little Neville. <sigh>  I know, I kill 
everybody
> off.  But I figure if I'm prepared it won't come as such a shock 
when JKR
> starts letting people die left and right!



And here are my two sickles worth:

I'm a closet Neville Longbottom fangirl, and I will cry too if he 
dies, but I agree completely with your idea of his two roads he'll 
have to face.

Will he choose the road less traveled by or will he be one of the 
sheep and follow the path of those before him who have turned evil?

I would like him to die a heroes death if he does infact have to die. 
(This would be the road less traveled by). I think it would be noble 
and everyone would think highly of him to do that =)

--Fyre Wood, who now has a list of 300 things smarter than neville on 
her website. Oh boy!






More information about the HPforGrownups archive