Trelawney deserves credit, But so does Ron!

[grey_wolf_c]

No: HPFGUIDX 42702

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Ambir Adams" <ambiradams at h...> wrote:
> I actually think Ron is a bit more accurate with his predictions, 
> although he doesn't realize it yet.  Most of everything he said to 
> Harry has happened, or did happen.  If you want me to find specifics 
> like quotes and page numbers I will.  I think Ron really has the gift 
> of sight, not Trelawney.  Sure she might have had two correct 
> preditictions but honestly, only two?

Ah, another convert for HAGRID WANTS BRASS DRAGONS AS PETS, ANSWERS, 
WANDS CRISS-CROSS or WANTON MORASS OF TOSH. Pity *I* don't buy the 
idea. Proof? Ron gets predictions right because he scouts almost all 
the possibilities, after all, and even then, it needs even more clever 
arguing about how he correctly predicted than to explain how Parvati 
expected a letter about the death of her rabbit. Any of the defenders 
of the above-named theories would like to come out and expose -in a 
nut-shell- their arguments?
 
> And she probably comes out for meals, so she very well could know 
> that Neville is a clutz.
> 
> Ryoko Blue ^_^

Nope, she doesn't come out to meals: Dumbledore mentions that she's not 
normally seen at meals when she joins the 12 staying over for the CoS 
Christmas meal (at least, I think it's CoS. It could be PoA, though).

Hope that helps,

Grey Wolf