The Magical Room Hiden in Hogwarts

malady579 Malady579 at hotmail.com
Tue Aug 20 01:54:17 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 42926

> As Sumbledore mentioned, he found this room only while wandering with
> an extremely full bladder - perhaps the room is not *always* a room
> filled with chamberpots, but rather a room that only shows itself when
> one is in great need or desire of something, and is then filled with
> that? Melody sort of hints at this in her post, though I'm not sure if
> this is what she meant... I think this would be much more interesting,
> as a plot device and in general, than another bathroom. :)
>
> ~ Jackie
>


Ooo, I like that.  It is a room that arrives and help you when you are
in great need.  Glad the room was full of chamber pots and not
urinals.  Somehow chamber pots are more...fitting to Dumbledore's old,
romantic character.  If that theory is so, then it leaves JKR with
many possibilities with plot lines.  I wonder if the room is
dependable to arrive or just a chance happening?  Is there a way to
call it?  I wonder also if Dumbledore has seen it before?  Way to much
to think about before bedtime.

Melody 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive