Chamber Pot Room As Portkey (WAS: The Magical Room Hidden in Hogwarts)

erisedstraeh2002 bdmorrp at budget.state.ny.us
Tue Aug 20 15:17:16 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 42944

Melody said (regarding the chamber pot room mentioned in GoF):

> It is a room that arrives and helps you when you are in great 
> need. <snip> I wonder if the room is dependable to arrive or 
> just a chance happening?  Is there a way to call it?  

and HF (yr awen) responded:
 
> I think there's evidence in the series to indicate that need-driven 
> magic is powerful stuff.  If something like the "Chamber(Pot) of 
> Secrets" room requires need to access it, it probably won't respond 
> to an ordinary incantation. 

Now me:

What if a witch or wizard could summon the chamber pot room when 
she/he has an urgent need to return to Hogwarts?  Hermione tells us 
over and over again that you can't Apparate within the Hogwarts 
grounds, which has led to speculation about how Dumbledore got back 
to Hogwarts so quickly to help Harry after he encounters Quirrellmort 
in PS/SS.  Perhaps the chamber pot room can be summoned in times of 
great need to return to Hogwarts quickly (sort of like a portkey).

This would also concur with Eloise's latin derivation of "mentioned" 
as meaning "thought of" - when you think of the room, you find 
yourself there!

~Phyllis
who loves HF's "Chamber(Pot) of Secrets" idea







More information about the HPforGrownups archive