Enchanted Objects (Re: A Map of very little Brain?)
prefectmarcus
prefectmarcus at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 30 19:19:39 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 43378
There have been several objects that act with a will of their own:
@Various mirrors comment upon the person using them.
@Photo and portrait images talk and react to their viewers. They
even go visiting other images.
@Suits of armor laugh at pratfalls.
@Doors that will only open if asked politely.
@Hogwarts' front doors can be trained to recongize people
@Mr. Weasley's car becomes wild in the forest
@Various action figures
@The Sorting Hat
And to the point of this discussion -
@The Marauder's Map
@Tom Riddle's Diary
All of these objects have one thing in common, they can think for
themselves. But where is their brain?
I think they capture the essense of people, rather than the people
themselves.
Look at Colin's photo of Harry and Lockhart. Image Harry refuses to
be seen with Image Lockhart. Harry certainly didn't program the
photo, neither did Lockhart or Colin. Harry's essense was captured
in it. A similar process must be involved elsewhere.
These essenses exist long after their originals have past on. Think
of all the portraits of past Hogwarts' Headmasters that are still
viable.
In the case of the Map's response to our favorite potions professor,
I think it is the reaction of the creators' 15-year-old-selves to
one.
Now, could Harry talk to James? Perhaps, but I doubt it would be
very satisfactory. It would be Harry talking to a 15-year-old boy
with three best buds hanging around. Map James simply is not Harry's
dad. Harry would do better looking at his dad's picture in the photo
album.
Marcus
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive