[HPforGrownups] Can Ghosts Drink?
jazmyn
jazmyn at pacificpuma.com
Sun Dec 1 01:27:18 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 47500
erisedstraeh2002 wrote:
>
> A question that occurred to me after watching the CoS movie (this is
> a canon-based question, I promise): Can ghosts drink? We know that
> Nearly Headless Nick tells Ron and Harry that he hasn't eaten in over
> 400 years in PS/SS, and all of the food at the Deathday party in CoS
> is rotten so that the ghosts can smell it as they pass through. But
> they can't *eat* it. So can they drink? Because wouldn't Nearly
> Headless Nick have had to drink the Mandrake draught in order to be
> un-petrified?
>
> It seems to me that if ghosts can't eat, they shouldn't be able to
> drink, either. But then how was Nearly Headless Nick restored?
>
> ~Phyllis
Maybe his condition wore off in time, as he could not be killed, being
already dead, maybe he is not material enough to remain petrified for
more then a few months. Or maybe one could take a plant sprayer and
mist him with the potion? Maybe there's a spell to make something
non-living 'ghosted', so that ghosts can get new clothes or ghost
items?
How would, in fact, ANY petrified person drink? Living or ghost?
Possibly the potion is applied externally?
Jazmyn
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive