Some Questions = Theories Wanted

The Real Makarni pat_mahony at hotmail.com
Wed Dec 4 11:42:49 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 47698

<daniel.brent at c...> wrote:
> 1) How would Ron have explained to the rest of the Weasley's 
about 
> the disappearence of Scabbers and aquiring Pig? We can see 
that they 
> do not know that Sirius is innocent in GoF and Ron supposedly 
has no 
> money... How would he explain Pig?

I agree with those people who point out that everyone thought 
Scabbers was dead, and he could just claim that Pig was a gift.


> 2)The Weasley's have a clock that tells each of them where 
each 
> member of the family is, home, work etc... Why then, during 
Harry and 
> Ron's adventures with the spiders, would the clock for Ron not 
appear 
> on "mortal peril"? Or when Ginny was in the Chamber or 
talking to Tom 
> wouldn't the Weasley's be straight over to Hogwarts, banging 
down 
> Dumbledore's door? Or when Ron was trapped with Sirius? 
The clock 
> doesn't know that he's innocent... And he's chained to a 
werewolf. 
> Why doesn't the clock tell the Weasely's that they are in "mortal 
> danger"?


Another possibility- the clock wasn't mentioned until Book 4. It is 
possible that the Weasley's bought it *after* the CoS incident.



> 5) How did Sirius know where to find Peter after the Potter's 
deaths? 
> He seems to track him down a little too easily... Did Peter plan 
that 
> Sirius find him in that particular street? And was it part of his 
and 
> Voldemort's original plan, to pretend to blow himself up, thus 
> framing Sirius for three murders?

I was under the impression that Pettigrew, in intending to frame 
Sirius, went after him, while Sirius, looking for vengeance, went 
looking for Peter. Only a matter of time before they met. . . 

That's all from me for now. . . See you all later
Roo





More information about the HPforGrownups archive