Harry Beats Voldemort: Actual talent or sheer dumb luck/ Sirius's remorse

[jksunflower2002]

No: HPFGUIDX 47805

 greg_a126 writes:

 
>> Now, on the topic of Sirius and remorse, or lack thereof:>>

Richelle replied:-
 
> I think the entire prank revolves around something we don't 
understand because we don't know all of the circumstances.  I think it stems from a history  between he and Snape that preceded Hogwarts.  Casting Snape as the Draco of the Maurader's years doesn't figure in.  I really doubt Harry, Ron or Hermione would set up a prank to kill Draco.  There's more to it than what 
went on at Hogwarts, in my opinion.

> Richelle
 

My thoughts: Perhaps, at the tender age of 16, Snape was alredy a DE 
and spying for Voldemort.  Sirius found this out, and decided to pull 
the "prank."  

Just a theory.

First posting (anywhere, ever.)  Going back to lurking.
Toad