Wizard religion (was Excusssse me.)
Jim Ferer <jferer@yahoo.com>
jferer at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 10 15:52:37 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48058
Janet:"So, is there no religion in the WW? To the best of my
knowledge, religion exists in all human cultures in some shape or
form, even atheists have some spiritual beliefs or opinions if you
sit them down and talk about it for long enough. So where does this
fit in in HP?"
We do see signs of at least traditions observed in the wizard world.
What are the two holidays that close the school? Christmas and
Easter. There are Christmas trees [an adopted pagan tradition] and
carols sung. So at least some Christian traditions are observed,
although what piety or lack of it that lies beneath it is a mystery.
You would think there has to be some religion somewhere. Some of the
students must come to school with religious beliefs, at least those
from the Muggle world. And you're right that every human society we
know of has something that qualifies as religion.
But why must we find it in JKR's work? How many novels based in our
own Muggle world mention religion? A few, but not many. Most have no
indication whatsoever that religion exists.
I always imagined that religion exists in the wizard world about like
it does in ours; most people aren't observant, some are, and
generally don't include it much in their daily lives and
conversations.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive