Worldwide Ministry? was, Thoughts on Hagrid's wand
Cindy <cid62@yahoo.com>
cid62 at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 10 18:13:35 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48067
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, midgiecat at a... wrote:
> I was under the impression that the Ministry of Magic was just
that, the
> Ministry of Magic, all inclusive, not just for Britain. It was
never called
> the MOM-Britain.
>
> Another point, I felt the headmaster/mistress of schools from the
other
> countries seemed to be under the jurisidiction/control of Crouch,
Fudge,
> Bagman, et al during the TWT, and remember Karkoroff being
questioned during
> the reign of VM - surely if the MOM was just for Britain he would
have been
> questioned in his own country under their MOM.
>
> I think the Ministry of Magic encompasses wizards everywhere.
Hello there....this is my first post on this group (although I have
been lurking for a while).
I'd like to respectfully counter (not a flame, just an alternate POV)
this theory with two facts mentioned in the books:
1. There is a Department of International Magical Cooperation - why
have one of those if there is only one Ministry?
2. There is a Bulgarian Minister of Magic (Obalonsk?) mentioned in
GOF. Surely he heads a Bulgarian ministry.
I could go on, but I think you get the idea. When I was writing my
fic I actually thought about this issue quite a bit. (I ended up
creating an American Department of Magic, which has multiple sub-
departments and is very bureaucratic, much like the actual US
government.)
Now Voldemort--I could see him wanting to head a worldwide magical
dictatorship....
Cheers,
Cindy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive