Wizard religion (was Excusssse me.)
bluesqueak <pipdowns@etchells0.demon.co.uk>
pipdowns at etchells0.demon.co.uk
Tue Dec 10 23:26:39 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48101
> Diane said: I can only imagine that it (religion) isn't mentioned
> in canon because JKR herself is only averagely religious and
> therefore it just hasn't come up yet.
>
> This goes for much of the UK where religious is tacit rather than
> fanatical. I am inclined to agree with your point about being a
> lapsed Christian (also grins) Christianity has appeared in canon
> in the form of Christmas so all we can assume really is that
> Hogwarts is nominally Christian much like the rest of the UK.
>
> Diane
I'd argue that Hogwarts and the WW are similar in religious variety
to the rest of the UK. A modern specialist school (which Hogwarts
effectively is) would be expected to be non-sectarian.
Religion is so very much in the background in the WW that it appears
to be a deliberate authorial decision.
JKR does use various Christian symbols (Harry's wand is made of
Holly which has been used as a Christian symbol, the Stag that is
James's patronus is also a symbol of St Godric, Sirius is Harry's
*Godfather*, Hedwig is the name of a Saint who had particular
concern for orphaned children, and so on).
This is probably not an accident. JKR is on record as attending
Church of Scotland services at the time the books were being planned
(Church of Scotland ref: Interview with Evan Solomon, CBC Newsworld
Hot Type (21 July 2000)
(http://cbc.ca/programs/sites/hottype_rowlingcomplete.html); and AOL
Chat -- May 2000.
Sectarianism is an *extremely* sensitive subject in parts of the UK.
People can get murdered simply because they happen to be of the
wrong religion or religious denomination. I can well see JKR
deciding that giving her wizards (or Harry himself ) a particular
religious 'brand' would provoke reactions that would interfere with
the story she wants to tell.
Pip
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive