Ministry jurisdiction(s) was; Thoughts on Hagrid's wand
jodel at aol.com
jodel at aol.com
Wed Dec 11 07:17:48 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48137
Brenda Wenelken states;
>> was under the impression that the Ministry of Magic was just that, the
Ministry of Magic, all inclusive, not just for Britain. It was never called
the MOM-Britain.
Another point, I felt the headmaster/mistress of schools from the other
countries seemed to be under the jurisidiction/control of Crouch, Fudge,
Bagman, et al during the TWT, and remember Karkoroff being questioned during
the reign of VM - surely if the MOM was just for Britain he would have been
questioned in his own country under their MOM. <<
As to whether other Ministries exist; The MoM for Bulgaria was with Fudge at
the World Cup. So clearly the British Ministry does not represent all of
Europe. Otoh, Fudge accepted the Cup for Ireland, so the British Ministry
does not represent only the modern-day UK. I suspect that the Ministry
jurisdictions do not exactly match the current political boundaries of Muggle
governments, but that there is at least some similarity to them.
As to the Death Eater trials; I suspect that these were a complex business
undertaken under a combination of jurisdictions, possibly hosted in Britian.
Or, given the basicaly anarchic structure of wizarding society, a DE may have
had to stand more than one trial if their alleged activities took place in
different Ministry's jurisdictions. Karkarof's trial appears to have dealt
primarily with crimes which took place in Britian, and virtually all of the
names he gave the court are presumed to be those of English wizards. (Doholov
may have been a resident alien.)
-JOdel
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive