Wands with no spells
Laura <metslvr19@yahoo.com>
metslvr19 at yahoo.com
Wed Dec 11 21:20:21 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48156
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, dangermousehq at h... wrote:
Alora says:
>>>
"Does that mean that the wand and it's owner are connected in some
way? Telepathy, or something of the like?"
>>>
Dan says:
>>>
That's more or less what I think--eventually wizards and witches
become so magically skilled they don't need to say the incantation
part of certain spells anymore. I think of the incantation
(alohomora, for example) as just being a word that triggers a desired
effect in your brain, which, in turn, causes it to manifest in the
real world.
>>>
I say:
I really like this idea, it makes a lot of sense. But then why did
Ron's levitating spell not work properly? Since we all know
it's "Wing-GAR-dium levi-O-sa" not "wingardium levio-SA" =)
I don't know if the words are totally useless, because what would be
the point in them? If their only purpose is to "remind" the wizard
of the spell, then it would be much more effective for the wizard to
personailze the spells and use words they closely associated with the
desired outcome.
Which leads me into a new question. Where did magic COME from? It
seems to be somewhat natural, as it can't be strictly "learned."
(i.e. you're born magical or you're not) so it doesn't seem as if
humans created it. So then how would they have discovered how to
*use* it? And how to make and use wands?
Well that's the end of my babbling
-Laura
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive