Question about Boggarts (WAS: About Werewolves)

Anne Palmer elena_evenstar at yahoo.com
Thu Dec 12 22:36:03 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 48249

Sherry Garfio <sgarfio at yahoo.com> wrote:
>>>>I have a question about the nature of
Boggarts.  During Lupin's class, the
Boggart turns into the full moon when 
Lupin confronts it....
Later, Lupin uses the Boggart to present
Harry with a Dementor in
order to practice the Patronus charm. 
This fake Dementor has the same effect
on Harry as a real Dementor....
My question, then, is this: 
If Harry is affected as though the Boggart 
were a real Dementor, why isn't Lupin affected 
as though the Boggart were the real
moon? <<<<

I think that the reason Harry was so affected by the boggart/dementor was because his fear of the dementor was so great, as well as fresh in his mind. If you'll recall, in book 4, he meets a boggart in the maze (in dementor form) and is unaffected. I think it has something to do with the level of experience the wizard has. 
~Anne~





More information about the HPforGrownups archive