Death in Book 5

annemehr <annemehr@yahoo.com> annemehr at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 20 14:47:26 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 48588

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mitchbailey82 
<MITCHBAILEY82 at H...>" <MITCHBAILEY82 at H...> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "armillarygirl 
> <renitentraven at h...>" <renitentraven at h...> wrote:
> >  I've often wondered if the death of a Harry *fan* mighn't be 
> Hedwig 
> > after J.K. Rowling stated in chat that Harry *may* get a new pet, 
> but 
> > she couldn't say more.
> >
 
<snip>

> I've always taken this inforamtion as possible proof for the death 
of 
> Hagrid - afterall if Hagird dies who's going to look after Fang?
> 
> I've also heard people suggest that when Dumbledore dies Harry might 
> get Fawlkes - so it coul also be taken as evidence for Dumbledores 
> death.
>
 
That was my first thought the minute I read that in the chat -- that 
Fawkes would choose to go to Harry when Dumbledore dies.  In the post 
previous to this one, Jazmyn suggests that Fawkes might just switch 
owners, and leave a living Dumbledore to go to Harry.  I see this as 
very unlikely; after all, one of the characteristics of phoenixes is 
that they are extremely loyal.

> Or Harry could just get a new pet.
> 
> Either way Harry doesn't need to lose Hedwig in order to get a new 
> pet - I'm sure he's quite capable of looking after 2 pets - although 
> what the Dursleys would think of another pet (especially if it was 
> Fang - judgng by Petunias reactions to Magres dog) is another thing 
> ;-)
> 
> 
> Michelle

I always sort of hoped that Harry would meet up with that snake from 
the zoo that he first talked to.  After all, I'm probably not alone in 
being disappointed that Harry uses his Parsletongue so seldom, and I 
like snakes.  Suppose the snake had trouble getting off the island -- 
hey, it could happen.  And then imagine the Dursleys' reactions when 
he brought *that* home and then started speaking to it! :-D

Anne





More information about the HPforGrownups archive