Marauder's Map
eloiseherisson at aol.com
eloiseherisson at aol.com
Mon Dec 23 12:40:51 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48715
In a message dated 23/12/2002 11:00:42 GMT Standard Time, corsa808 at yahoo.com
writes:
>
> Yet another question: How did Crouch Jr-as-Moody know how to operate
> [the Marauder's Map] That has probably been discussed before so no need to
> answer...
>
I'm not sure that it has, actually. I was wondering the same thing myself the
other day, until I recalled that the Map was already activated at the time
that Crouch-Moody took posession of it. I presume that as he didn't know how
to wipe it clean, he just kept it in its active state.
Like Cheryl, what I *would* like to know, however, is how the twins learned
to operate it. My theory is that it recognised suitable owners in Fred and
George and instructed them in its use.
When they found it in Filch's filing cabinet was it active, or inactivated?
If it was inactive, how did Filch know it was "highly dangerous"?
If it was active, why didn't Filch use it himself in his constant war against
the students, instead of filing it away? Surely it would have been
exceedingly tempting for a Squib with such an insatiable desire to get
students into trouble to have in his control such a useful and powerful piece
of magic.
~Eloise
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive