SHIP (with some FF) Re: H/H vs R/H
pippin_999 <foxmoth@qnet.com>
foxmoth at qnet.com
Mon Dec 23 17:49:08 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48726
> Pippin responding to Eb:"Now see, this is where I think H/H
becomes canon-challenged. You seem to be saying that
Hermione would be suitable for Harry onlyif he comes through
with his fame and his power intact. I agree."
Jim:
> I see Hermione as one of the few people who would be past
all that. I believe she knows Harry better than perhaps any of his
contemporaries, and accepts him completely for who he is.
She's very clear on what she believes, and if he's worshipped or
reviled, he's the same Harry as far as she's concerned. She
depends on nobody else for what she thinks.<<
Maybe what people think isn't important to Hermione. But it's very
important to Harry. His fear of failure, and of being seen to fail,
is intense. Let me put it this way. Once Voldemort is defeated, do
you think Harry would want to live on in the wizarding world if his
powers or his reputation were lost beyond recall?
I think he would rather go back to the Muggle world than have to
live in the magical world without magic, or if he was "stained" as
Ebony put it.
But do you think Hermione would want to live as a Muggle if that
was the only way she could be with him, or is her life as a witch
more important to her? May she be spared such a choice! But I
haven't yet heard from anyone who thinks Hermione would be
the ideal match for Harry under such circumstances. Yet why not,
if love is all that matters?
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive