Lupin is James

[Strix <kethlenda@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 48844

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "silveroak_us <
silveroak_us at y...>" <silveroak_us at y...> wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "sharana.geo 
> <sharana.geo at y...>" <sharana.geo at y...> wrote at great length 
and 
> eloquently concerning a theory that Lupin died along with Lily 
and 
> that James is now masquerading.
> 
> Small, teensy, itsy-bitsy problem, IMHO...
> 
> During the confrontation between Voldemort and Harry near 
the end of 
> the fourth book, Voldemort's wand shows its previous spells. 
These 
> include the deaths of Cedric, Lily, and James(!) This would 
> constitute pretty strong proof that James died when Lily did.
> (I will gloss over the apparent inconsistency in some editions 
of the 
> fourth book concerning the order of Lily's and James's deaths)
> 
> ** Martin Miggs, the Mad Muggle **

But the theory can still stand, if Real!Lupin was in James'  body 
when he died, and looked like James rather than himself.  *
shrug*

Strix