Lupin is James

[Potter Hermione forever <nj13guy@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 48866

> I believe that before the night Voldemort was defeated, Remus and 
> James switched bodies without telling anyone (except Lily) and that 
> it was Remus who died, not James. James lives in Remus's body. 
> 

> sharana

It seems like a pretty amazing theory. :-)

But, I am not sure how plausible it is !

Switching bodies? You mean they switch their souls?

This is pretty deep.

When James's echo comes out of Voldemort's wand at the end of GoF, he 
did not seem to say any such thing. I mean If he were Remus, he would 
have said so. Echos are not supposed to lie. Or do they?

The idea of one or both of harry's parents being alive does seem very 
sweet, but I have not seen any concrete evidence which points to that 
way till now.

The only pointer can be Harry imagining seeing his father in CoS.
But, that was quickly cleared as he seeing himself in the past!
Or was it?

I hope JKR releases Book 5 pretty soon.
I am going craZy with all these theories here.

But, it is a cool idea.
I hope JKR makes it come true.

'Potter Hermione Forever'