Sucking & Blowing of Souls (was: Crouch in 9)

[Steve <bboy_mn@yahoo.com>]

No: HPFGUIDX 49034

Both Elkins and Catlady have discussed the possibily of Crouch Jr
somehow through some miraculous process (bones of his father or
whatever) being revived, being OK again.

That makes me wonder, if a Dementor can 'suck' out your soul, would
that also imply that he can 'blow' it back? 

Could Voldemort break open Azkaban, find out what happened to Barty
Jr, and order the Dementor who took it, to give Bary Jr his soul back?

Perhaps, once a soul is lost it's lost forever, then again....


I do tend to agree with Elkins that most secondary villains are a one
shot deal. They are part of the story they are in, and are never heard
from again. But I find the concept of returning someones soul very
intriguing. Perhaps the return of Barty's soul could be the setup for
Sirius losing his soul and later in the story having it returned.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Suddenly off on a new subject....

The new place in the wizard's world that Harry will visit. Could it be
Godric's Hollow, Egypt, the Ministry of Magic, or .... perhaps Azkaban?

What if, in an effort to clear Sirius's name, the Ministry agrees to a
new impartial and fair trial during which they will weigh the original
evidence and the new evidence, and make a new ruling on Sirius's guilt
or innocents. But, the only way the Ministry will consider it, is if
Sirius turns himself in as a show of good faith. Which means that
until the end of the trial, Sirius is back in Azkaban. OR... it could
be a sham of a trial and Sirius, despite four witnesses and
Dumblefore's support, is convict, or worse yet, they change their mind
about the trial and send him to Azakaban ,and maybe even to the
Dementor's kiss. 

I see a shame of a trial, execution of the kiss set for a later date.
Dumbledore, Harry, and Company must break into Azkaban which is now
thought to be under the assumed influence of Voldemort, and break
Sirius out. 

Hey... it's just a thought.

bboy_mn