Sirius Motivations:"The Prank was Snape's Fault

uilnslcoap devin.smither at yale.edu
Wed Feb 6 17:07:46 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 34756

Tex wrote:

> I guess I'm in the Club.  AFAIKT, Cannon doesn't tell us Sirius' 
> motive for the prank, i.e. why Serius Told Snape about the Shack.
> I think Snape spiked Serius' pumpkin juice with Veritaserum and
> caused him thus to babble.  Recall in GF that he threatened to do
> this to Harry.
> 
> So, why didn't Serius explain that he had been juiced?  He may not
> know about it, himself.  If the serum is anything like Imperius,
> what you do just seems like a good thing to do, at the time. So,
> Serius himself my not know why he did it.

Hmmm...well, I have my doubts about the whole Veritaserum theory.  
Yes, Snape is often angry for no good reason, but I doubt even Snape 
could be angry at Sirius for endangering him if the only reason 
Sirius endangered him was that he was under the influence of 
Veritaserum.  I think it was just a dumb, very stupid and childish 
thing Sirius did, and I LIKE Sirius, so there ya go.

Devin






More information about the HPforGrownups archive