[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape knew about the passageway

[Amanda]

No: HPFGUIDX 34817

Judyserenity mentioned:
  By the way, there are also a bunch of other passageways that Lupin knows about (such as the one that goes from the one-eyed witch to Honeydukes.)  We don't know if Dumbledore is aware of these passageways; Snape clearly is not, as he examines the one-eyed witch and doesn't discover its secret. 
  ----->this is Amanda now.
  I want to point out, to no particular end, that the Marauder's Map itself may be a red herring. It has made us focus on the passageways to such an extent that we have forgotten there may be others that not even the marauders found (as witnessed by the Chamber of Secrets). I think there will be other really important unknown passageways, which will catch us totally by surprise because the omniscience of the Map has made us forget that while it is enchanted to reveal the identities of the people it shows, it cannot be enchanted to reveal passageways its makers knew nothing about.

  Just a thought.

  --Amanda


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]